Third-party administrators (TPAs) in the property casualty insurance industry play a vital role in managing claims for insurers, self-insured companies, and policyholders. They act as intermediaries, handling tasks such as processing claims, conducting investigations, and facilitating settlements. Despite their crucial function, property casualty TPAs often struggle with a poor reputation. This article delves into the factors contributing to this negative perception and why many stakeholders—insurers, policyholders, and legal professionals—express dissatisfaction with TPAs.
Why Do Property Casualty TPAs Have a Bad Reputation?
- Lack of Technical Skills
When discussing TPAs there is a presumption and acceptance (!) that those handling the claims are not going to be technically sound. TPAs may not have staff with specialized knowledge, particularly, in high severity matters or specialty lines of businesses which can lead to errors in assessing liability and/or damages, interpreting policy language, or assessing settlement value. This technical gap can result in inefficient claims handling, wrongful denials, and ultimately be very costly to carriers and self-insureds (think lack of proper risk transfer assessment, overvaluing/undervaluing claims, potential bad faith).
- Perceived Lack of Accountability
One of the primary criticisms of TPAs is the perception that they lack accountability to policyholders. Unlike insurers, who have a direct contractual relationship with their clients, TPAs are external entities hired by the insurer or a self-insured company. This lack of direct responsibility to the claimant can create an impression that TPAs are less invested in providing quality service or resolving claims efficiently. This disconnect can result in slow claims processing and poor communication, leaving claimants frustrated.
- Delays in Claims Processing
Delays in handling claims are a frequent complaint when dealing with TPAs. Timely claims resolution is crucial in the property casualty space, where insured parties may be dealing with significant financial or emotional distress after a loss. Unfortunately, TPAs are sometimes seen as bogged down in bureaucracy, leading to prolonged investigations and approvals. Carriers and self-insureds often cite slow responses, excessive documentation requests, and unnecessary delays as key reasons for dissatisfaction.
- Inconsistent Service Quality
TPAs manage claims for multiple clients with diverse policies and guidelines, which can result in inconsistent service quality. Carriers and self-insureds may experience varying levels of expertise, attention, and efficiency depending on which TPA is handling their claim and how closely the TPA adheres to the insurer’s guidelines. The quality of service may differ drastically from one claim to the next, creating an unpredictable experience for policyholders and generating frustration over inconsistent outcomes.
- Cost-Cutting Measures That Impact Service
Many TPAs are hired as a cost-saving measure by insurers and self-insured companies. While this can benefit insurers by reducing administrative expenses, it often leads to corner-cutting that negatively impacts service quality. TPAs may be incentivized to reduce claim payouts or minimize settlement offers to meet performance metrics, which can feel unfair. In some cases, the pressure to reduce costs may result in subpar investigations or denial of legitimate claims, further damaging the TPA’s reputation.
These are the reasons that Tivra is forging a new path. It’s time for carriers and self-insureds to demand more. At Tivra we:
- Provide clear and consistent communication about the claims process and timelines.
- Ensure that all claims are handled with exceptional level of professionalism and technical expertise (yes, our claims professionals are actual specialists so a GL adjuster will not handle your E&O claims!)
- Implement more efficient claims processing systems and reducing unnecessary bureaucracy that will speed up claim resolutions and reduce delays.
- Take greater responsibility for the outcomes of claims and work to ensure that we fairly, timely, and accurately adjudicate all claims.
#ClaimsExcellence #ClaimsQuality #TechnicalSkills #BestTPA
Add comment
Comments
Would love to hear more about this.
Ms. Kumar,
We sent you an email to discuss further! Looking forward to connecting.
Thanks,
Tivra